10 Best Toilet Seats – Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

Toilet seats are those bathroom items that we all need – but don’t particularly give a second thought to. “It it fits, I sits” – or so the saying goes.

Still, we spend 5 minutes several times a day on the toilet – and even more if you own a smartphone. If we’re going to be using it this much, we might as well make it comfortable. And considering today’s technology, we have many options.

toilet seat

Best Toilet Seats - Our Top Rated Picks

If you’re looking for the best toilet seat that will make you feel like a king on the throne, then you have come to the right place. This article will offer you a few tips, but also direct you towards some popular choices.

Model

Type

Shape

Links

TOTO SS114#11


(Our Top Pick)

Traditional

Elongated

KOHLER K-4648-47


(Runner Up)

Traditional

Round

Bidet

Elongated

Padded

Round

Traditional

Elongated

Heated

Elongated

Traditional

Elongated

Traditional

Elongated

Traditional

Elongated

Traditional

Round

Reviews of the Best Toilet Seats

If you’re out of ideas for your bathroom, here are some toilet seats that are popular among users.

1. TOTO SS114#11 Transitional Toilet Seat – Best Toilet Seat of 2018

For this reason, this toilet seat features a SoftClose system. It will not only keep things quiet, but it will also prevent any injury from happening.

The molded bumpers also ensure that this elongated toilet seat is as comfortable as possible.

The design is fairly ergonomic, fitting even in a medium-sized bathroom.

The Good

  • Ergonomic design
  • Affordable price
  • Comfortable molded bumpers
  • Quiet SoftClose system

The Bad

  • The plastic in the hinges is weak
  • It feels cheap

What's the Bottom Line?

If you are looking for an affordable seat that will fit almost every toilet, then you may want to give this TOTO model a try.


2. KOHLER K-4648-47 - Runner-Up

While it may look like plastic, this toilet seat is actually made from compression molded wood – a material that will speak for its durability. Plus, its looks will be nothing like any average toilet seat.

Considering that it’s a round toilet seat, this one will not work with an elongated toilet; however, given the right fit, it will save you a lot of space in the bathroom.

Thanks to its rounded edges, this toilet seat is very comfortable to sit on.

 The color is also neutral enough so that it can fit almost every bathroom design; however, it will work best with those following cream hues.

The Good

  • Simple design
  • Compact form fit for small bathrooms
  • Affordable price
  • Comfortable round edges

The Bad

  • It may be uncomfortable for larger people
  • The hinges are weak

What's the Bottom Line?

If you are looking for something low cost that does a good job as a “toilet seat,” then the Kohler seat is definitely something you should look into.


3. Ellegantz GenieBidet Seat – Best Bidet Toilet Seat

If you dislike using toilet paper roll after toilet paper roll, then you may want to go for a bidet toilet seat – namely, the GenieBidet seat.

This model will connect to your plumbing and will send a spray of warm water up your posterior and private parts – therefore providing you a thorough cleanse.

The advantage of this bidet toilet seat is that it also features seat heating. This way, you won’t have to feel cold during winters, when all you want to do go to the bathroom in the middle of the night.

The Good

  • Heated seat
  • Adjustable temperatures
  • Affordable price
  • Comfortable

The Bad

  • The water spray angle is too wide
  • The plastic feels somehow cheap

What's the Bottom Line?

If you are looking for something modern that will allow you to feel clean after exiting the bathroom, then the GenieBidet toilet seat will be a worthy acquisition.


4. Mayfair 13EC 000 Soft Toilet Seat – Best Padded Toilet Seat

Having conventional nut-and-bolt type hinges, this toilet seat can easily be taken off to be cleaned or replaced.

Furthermore, considering that the fabric is faux leather, all you have to do is wipe it off.

The design is very stylish and will make every bathroom look elegant.

It will fit every environment – no matter if it’s vintage or modern-looking.

The Good

  • It is very comfortable thanks to the padding
  • It fits every round bowl that was made in the US
  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to install and remove
  • Durable construction

The Bad

  • Faux leather may feel weird on skin contact – especially during summer
  • Prone to stains

What's the Bottom Line?

Those looking for an extra dose of comfort may find great value in the Mayfair padded toilet seat.


5. TOTO SS154#11 – Best Traditional SoftClose Toilet Seat

This TOTO model is popular among those looking for something simple – yet effective and durable. Featuring heavy-duty hinges, this toilet seat was created to endure even heavier weights.

Its elongated design makes it very comfortable to sit on, even as a tall person. It’s perfect for every bathroom size – although it may not be recommended for extremely narrow spaces.

This toilet seat also features a soft-close system that prevents the much-hated toilet slam from occurring. Plus, it prevents injuries – like your fingers getting stuck where they shouldn’t.

The Good

  • SoftClose action
  • Resistant to chemicals
  • Comfortable contour

The Bad

  • Decreased durability
  • The SoftClose system may stop working after some time

What's the Bottom Line?

If you are looking for a traditional toilet seat that is both comfortable and quiet, then this TOTO model should definitely be the right choice for you.


6. Brondell L60-EB – Best Heated Toilet Seat

If there’s something that we really hate about winter, it’s the fact that it gets the toilet seat very cold. For this reason, the Brondell heated toilet seat is literally god sent.

Featuring 3 adjustable temperatures, you can choose the one that feels most comfortable for you. It takes only a few seconds to heat up.

This toilet seat is also equipped with LED lights that can be activated by the press of a button.

This way, you will be able to see the toilet if you want to use it at night – but don’t want to wake the whole house while you’re at it.

The Good

  • Fast-heating system
  • LED lights illuminate the way
  • SoftClose action
  • Fits all standard toilet sizes

The Bad

  • The heat doesn’t always go across the whole seat
  • The plastic wingnuts have to be tightened periodically

What's the Bottom Line?

The Brondell LumaWarm will keep your warm and light your way at all times. It’s a good option if your area tends to be particularly cold.


7. American Standard 5325.010.222 – Best Budget Toilet Seat

Those who are on a tight budget will also like this American Standard toilet seat. Made from solid plastic, this seat was made to last, and can withstand weight that goes over 200 lbs.

The design is very attractive – no matter how you look at it, you originally think it’s made of porcelain. It will look great in any bathroom – no matter if it sports a modern or a traditional look.

This model also features a convenient Slow-Close system that prevents the lid from slamming noisily against its “other half.” It’s a good option if you share a home with other people.

The Good

  • Slow Close system
  • Easily lifted and placed down
  • Attractive design
  • Comfortable seating

The Bad

  • The hinges are weak

What's the Bottom Line?

If you are looking for something simple, expensive, and that will not leave a hole in your wallet, then you may want to give the American Standard a try.


8. Mayfair 148SLOWA - Best Value for the Money

If you are going to pay a sum of money on a toilet seat, you want to make sure it won’t get broken on the first try.

This toilet seat was made from molded wood, meaning that it’s entirely environmentally friendly.

Plus, it’s very easy to clean; all it needs is a couple of wipes and you are done.

Featuring a Whisper-Close system, this seat is closed quietly with a tap, therefore preventing any pinched fingers and slamming.

   The Good

  • Durable molded wood
  • Easily installed and maintained
  • Comfortable fit
  • Quiet close system

  The Bad

  • It does not handle weight past 250 lbs
  • It is prone to stains

What's the Bottom Line?

If your budget is really tight and you are not particularly picky about what you are buying, then this toilet seat should definitely do the trick.


9. Bemis 7800TDG000 Plastic Toilet Seat – Best Secure Toilet Seat

If you’ve gotten tired of your toilet seats constantly coming off after a few months, then you want a seat that will securely stay in its place.

Featuring a STA-TITE seat fastening system, this one will never loosen, even after some time has passed.

Made from heavy-duty plastic, this toilet seat is fairly durable, considering the price that you pay for it.

Furthermore, since the edges are rounded, it’s very comfortable to sit on – even for longer periods of time.

The Good

  • Made of plastic, so it has increased durability
  • Modern design
  • Strong enough to handle a lot of weight

The Bad

  • It does not have slow or silent close system
  • It is prone to stains

What's the Bottom Line?

The Bemis toilet seat is simple, affordable – yet very effective. It will hold out for several years, provided you offer proper maintenance.


10. Bath Royale Premium – Best Round Toilet Seat

This toilet is highly versatile, mainly because it’s compatible with every round toilet bowl that was made in the States.

Plus, since it has a capacity of 400lbs, it’s the preferred option for overweight people.

The seat features a SoftClose system that prevents the lid from slamming noisily. This can further increase the life of the seat since it won’t be prone to cracks anymore.

The Bath Royale also features a high gloss finish that will prevent it from getting stains or attracting germs. Lastly, it is also easily cleaned – either with a cloth or by removing it completely.

   The Good

  • Durable construction
  • SoftClose action
  • High weight capacity
  • Comfortable design

   The Bad

  • The SoftClose action is too slow

What's the Bottom Line?

If you are looking for a toilet seat that will withstand any kind of weight throughout time, then you may want to give the Bath Royale a try. There’s a reason they call it “royal.”


How to Choose the Right Toilet Seat - A Buyer's Guide

This may come as a surprise to you, but the “if it fits, I sits” idea should not be applied here. A toilet seat is not only a matter of preference and comfort but also a matter of design to your bathroom.

For this reason, there are various factors that you should consider when choosing a toilet seat.

toilet seat

Mount Type

This may not seem like an issue to you, but the mount type of your toilet seat is very important. You may go for the conventional bolt-and-nut type – or you can go for the integral bolt-and-nut.

A conventional bolt-and-nut type is generally the preferred option since it is easy to add and remove. On the other hand, an integral bolt-and-nut mount will have to be drilled in and out – making it fairly troublesome to be removed if needed.

Material

Plastic is the most common material, considering that it’s the cheapest. Furthermore, since today’s plastic went through many treatments, it is also very durable.

Depending on the brand, the seat may also have coatings that prevent staining or the accumulation of bacteria.

You may also opt for wood and cushioned seats. Wood is classy and offers every bathroom that “vintage” look – but it may swell if there’s too much moisture in the air.

Cushioned seats will not swell, but the fabric may rip at some point. It is still the most comfortable choice since it’s soft and fluffy.

Types - Traditional, Open Front, Bidet

There are several types of toilet seats that you could opt for, all of them having different features.

For instance, if you want something simple, you may want to go for a traditional toilet seat – the one that you see in almost every house.

Some people, on the other hand, prefer open-front toilet seats. Not only will this type of toilet prevent toilet drip stains during urination, but it will also prevent their private parts from coming into contact with the seat.

Those who want to go all-the-way modern may opt for a bidet toilet seat. These seats have special nozzles that take warm water out of a small tank. That water is further sprayed on your private areas, giving you a thorough cleansing after you did your business.

Consider the Bowl Shape

When it comes to shapes, you may go for elongated, round, or contemporary. Elongated toilet seats offer more thigh space, but they are more voluminous – making them more appropriate for larger bathrooms.

Round toilet seats represent the more appropriate choice for smaller bathrooms, where space is already as limited as it is. However, since these seats do not offer as much thigh space, taller people might find them rather uncomfortable.

Contemporary toilet seats are not too round, but not too elongated either. They are still referred to as “elongated,” but in truth, they are a bit smaller.

While most toilet seats were made so that “one size fits all,” you may still want to know the shape of your toilet before buying the seat.

Benefits of a Toilet Seat

Those who have ever tried to do their business on a seatless toilet don’t even need to ask themselves this question: why on earth would I need a toilet seat?

Well, here’s a thought: how much did it hurt you when you were forced to sit on a seatless toilet? Its margins are thin and hard – which makes it uncomfortable for anyone trying to sit on it.

Not to mention that you feel like you’re falling into the toilet each time because there’s too much space. A toilet seat will make you feel secure on the toilet – and also comfortable enough to let you finish that Angry Birds level.

In a nutshell, why do we need toilet seats? Well, because:

  • check
    They are comfortable
  • check
    They let you sit securely
  • check
    They keep the bacteria out when the seat is down
  • check
    They complete the look of your bathroom

We never even think why we need a toilet seat; we just know that it has to be there.

Final Thoughts

Buying a toilet seat is not actually as simple as we may have thought – but with just a little bit of research, everyone can flawlessly find the perfect one.

Some want a bidet. Some want a SoftClose system. Others simply want something cheap that will keep them comfortable. Needless to say, there’s something on the market for everyone.

Hopefully, we managed to help narrow things down with this article. No matter if you just follow our tips or opt for our suggestions, you are bound to find something for your taste.


Leave a Comment